"Colonia Dignidad": reviews of the movie

izidubedube zezopolitiko saa anarchic ukuba kwaphuphumela kumazwe South American 70s Ekuqaleni kwenkulungwane yama-20, kancinane films wadubula phawu: abalawuli ubabalweyo documentary yemihla, yelo xesha le "imfazwe zimdaka" eArgentina kunye neempawu mdibi eChile.

Film «Colonia Dignidad" iqwalasele kubahleli ichongwe njengenye amalinge kakhulu yimpumelelo kinoremeslennikov ukutsala umdla hlabathi ukuba iziganeko eChile. I tape ibonisa iziganeko eziye zenzeke kweli lizwe ukususela ekufikeni ukuba amandla ndawonye eyayikhokelwa Salvador Allende ekumiselweni lozwilakhe Augusto Pinochet. Producer-mlawuli Florian Gallenberg bhanyabhanya i movie "Colonia Dignidad", ngokusekelwe ibali lakhe wasentsomini eyayiza kwenzeka khona eneneni amathanga zamahlelo, leyo, enyanisweni, yaba entolongweni amabanjwa ezopolitiko.

indaba

"Uluntu Accounting kunye nezemfundo" Dignidad "" yasekwa ngowe-1961 e Chile, yaye yaziwa ngokuba kwiparadesi esemhlabeni, lo idyll. Enyanisweni, ngaphantsi ndinamaphupha screen ihlelo ezifihlakeleyo, nto leyo likhokelwa Paul Schaefer olungumbandezeli - ngokukhawuleza Nazi ngoozwilakhe (eyadlalwa Mikael Nyukvist). Xa kwafika amandla, Jikelele Pinochet, apho aqale uthumela uso ebantwini ukuba ukuhlala edlulileyo kwi "uluntu" waba esihogweni ophilayo.

Lasiwa kumzabalazo weSocialism, intatheli oselula, inzalelwane eJamani, Daniyeli (Daniyeli Brühl), kunye nentombi yakhe, sisi waseJamani Lena (Emma Watson), ukuchaneka kwazo zezopolitiko babanjwa. Woman emva kokukhululwa elide kwetyala, kwaye mfana elindele isiphelo esibi; yena wathunyelwa "Dignidad", apho ityala kunye nabalandeli ezaneza ihlelo lonqulo. Bonke abangenayo iindonga thanga abasayi kubuyela kulo.

Zibeke inkululeko nobomi babo, uLena, phantsi ngesebe le abalandeli izithethe wathumela ngokuzithandela kwi "Dignidad" ubephethwe ngethemba ukugcina nesithandwa sakhe. Eli bali ifilimu "Colonia Dignidad". Inkcazelo enikiweyo ngasentla, aliqulathanga nabaphangi zehlabathi.

Ngokuchasene nentsukaphi politbataly

EzeMbali kunye nezopolitiko Drama "Colonia Dignidad" reviews of the movie ezifunyenweyo iphambene. Iingcali skeptical ngokubhekiselele kwiprojekthi Gallenberger, wabonisa ukuba ibali oza documentary film, kuba zininzi kakhulu amanani zembali kunye nemiba ekhankanywe. Kodwa ke, njengoko nkqu ababengakholwa kakhulu lukhuni, lo mfanekiso ushukumayo "ubuxoki yileyo." Mhlawumbi yiloo nto "Colonia Dignidad" yokureyitha phantsi uguqulelo IMDb ngu 7.10. Ingakumbi mfanekiso kinoprolog ifuze tape, "Yintoni ntoni xa lomlilo" Gregor Schnitzler. Gallenberger ngenkuthalo exaggerates umxholo ubuhlobo kunye nothando sizoku lwisana amadabi ezopolitiko.

Ushwankathe-

component Visual womzobo "Colonia Dignidad" iimpendulo leengcali ezichongiweyo njenge ogqibeleleyo - ukususela ekuqaleni ukuya kwisakhelo lokugqibela. Ngaphandle kwento yokuba ibali izele lithemba, zwabha ndibuhlungu kunye ombane eliguquguqukayo, iqulethe imibala ukukhanya: imibala efudumeleyo, ubuhle, amazwi zabantwana. Ekuqaleni kwebali ababhali ngabom ukubonisa ujonge ezimnandi, indawo yokuhlala ngokugqibeleleyo, landlelwe kaDaniyeli. Cosiness yenza nomfuziselo ngokwalama, yonke imihla indlu leyo buzane livumba uthando ngenxa phambi Lena. Kodwa ke imeko esitratweni ngokupheleleyo esahlukileyo. Le film "Colonia Dignidad" becala eyakhelwe phezu ukuchasana. Harmony wobomi umlinganiswa ophambili wamginya ngephanyazo, yaye emva koko iqala uvavanyo crazy, apho kufuneka ukuthobela ngathi ukuba sibe rhoqo ukuluqaphela.

Ukuze isangqa emxinwa

Drama "Colonia Dignidad" bagxeki babiza iifilimu ukuba isangqa nemxinwa mbali engahlawulwayo. Ke umlawuli German Florian Gallenberger ngokukodwa ngeziganeko zembali kunye nezopolitiko (msebenzi wakhe wangaphambili, "John Rabe" lunikezelwa imfazwe eJapan kunye neTshayina, obugutyungelwe kwabulawa e Nanjing), ngokudubula iifilim feature, ukwandisa abaphulaphuli ekujongwe bayamenywa ukuba bathathe inxaxheba kwimveliso kwe tape yehlabathi ongumdlali edumileyo Emmu Uotson. Njengophume iye ekugqibeleni wakwazi ukuba uyeke ukuba Hermione.

Kuninzi Imizobo mihla abalinganiswa ababhinqileyo uthathe indawo vtoroplanovyh, ukufikelela zothando injongo abalinganiswa abaphambili eyindoda, okanye umtsalane yazo yendalo. Ezi nketho kuphela uSara Connor ngo "terminator" kunye Ripley ukusuka 'Alien ". Ngoku ingaba ngokukhuselekileyo kwaye ubhedu Lena Watson. Makungaziwa ukuba uthetha isixhobo egqibeleleyo kuliwe bengaxhobanga, kodwa amandla ayo ngaphakathi into engenasiphelo.

The main inzuzo

Watson Heroine ngobukroti uleyisayo zonke iinzima, ungayekwa ngokwakhe. "Colonia Dignidad" (reviews of the movie isiqinisekiso) kwakungayi kuba kakhulu ngaphandle Emma, ngubani wakwazi ukubaleka iphulo kokulingana ngokwesini. Le tape yi ityala inqabile apho Heroine ukhulula hero, kunye neemvakalelo zakhe zibonakala yanelisayo ngaphezu kwakhe.

Daniel Brühl, waphumelela amawonga abagxeki emva kokuthatha inxaxheba film "Inglourious Basterds", "Bye Good, uLenin!", "Uhlanga", "I Fifth Estate", "I wayenguMphindezeli Lokuqala" ngasemva obambeleyo Watson ebilahlekile. Kodwa Bruhl ngoku omnye ethandwa kwaye kwafunwa emva iinkwenkwezi movie eJamani. Umdlalo "Colonia Dignidad" kwakhona ababukeli Kucetyiswa ukuba ukubukela ngenxa esiyibona sokubambela duo Watson - Brühl, kudlala indima ephambili. Kanti ke, naxa kwakukho abalinganiswa esembindini eqaqambileyo ongaphambili womfanekiso kuhlala Colonia Dignidad.

ububi ecocekileyo

Le kokufa le ochasene kwi umboniso izenzo yovalo Paul Schaefer, leyo bazalwe ngempumelelo Mikael Nyukvist. Xa kwimbali cinema yehlabathi Iintlobo isimilo ezinjalo ingaqhelekanga, kodwa umzobi nethamsanqa ngokwaneleyo ndahlukile ngenxa charisma yayo nanto. Umlinganiswa umdla kakhulu - umshumayeli, imambathisa inkohlakalo yakhe sokwazi, ukuphakama anxanwe, ndlongo "ukuthanda kukaThixo" kwaye amaza amanene. Schaefer, lokudala yokoyika iintliziyo zabanye, iba nefuthe elikhulu ebandleni. Yena utyhola amalungu ehlelo yakhe vice, kodwa ayikho ngaphandle kwesono.

Le film "Colonia Dignidad" hero Nyquist kulingana ugandaganda enamandla, ohlohliweyo kwisiqingatha kakuhle abantu emhlabeni, ngaxeshanye bazizalisa ngothuli. UPawulos - oku kunjalo, xa kukho ububi ngokwayo, yaye kungekho sizathu. Mikael Nyqvist abanyamezela krelekrele umsebenzi ezibekwe ababhali mfanekiso. isimilo sakhe esengqiqweni, akunamsebenzi khangela obangela cartoonish. Umdlali yaziwa kumboniseli ifilimu "Girl kunye Dragon Tattoo," "Akukho xhulumaniso" yaye "Mission Ayinakwenzeka."

Umdlalo High ezikumgangatho

Kufuphi kuvuthondaba filimu likufutshane umoya uxinzeleko "Argo" - umsebenzi bena Affleka. Kodwa ke ukubaleka baphambili Gallenberger projekthi zange ndicinge kakuhle waza walungisa. Umbukeli ubona ithuba ixesha ukuba abalinganiswa kweli thanga, enkosi amakhadi zibanga ukushenxiswa zazo ezininzi. Babelana ibali ngezahluko kunye qwa, oko kukuthi ngumhla sokuhlala kwakho. I-script wemidlalo Torsten Wenzel umele anconywe, kubhaliwe ngokugqibeleleyo. Iincwadi zeempendulo tape kufumana nayiphi ungenangqiqo, engeyomfuneko iyelenqe ukujika kunye namasebe, kwaye abalinganiswa uyaphila ngokwenene.

sinqumo

Film "Colonia Dignidad" izimvo kwiingcaphephe bacebisa ukuba ukubukela, kungakhathaliseki ukuba yindoda, iimbono ngayo ubomi. Ngapha koko, ukuba ngokuyintloko umdlalo nemfanelo Qinisekisa ukuba ushiye uphawu kwi intliziyo uzibonayo.